Rochester Floor Pros · Compare

Flooring comparisons — Rochester, NY

The 10 most-googled binary decisions Rochester homeowners weigh when researching flooring. Each page is a 5-minute read with the actual decision criteria.

Refinish existing hardwood
vs
Replace with new
refinish when wear layer is 1/16"+ remaining; replace at <1/16" or extensive water damage
Solid hardwood
vs
Engineered hardwood
solid for refinishability (4-7x); engineered for moisture-prone areas + basement install
Hardwood
vs
LVP (luxury vinyl plank)
hardwood for premium look + resale value; LVP for waterproof + pet-friendly + DIY-installable
LVP
vs
Laminate
LVP for waterproof + thicker wear layer; laminate for budget + better realism in higher-end
Ceramic/porcelain tile
vs
LVP (luxury vinyl plank)
tile for water + heat resistance; LVP for warmth + DIY install + lower cost
Oil-based polyurethane
vs
Water-based polyurethane
oil for amber warmth + 10-yr durability; water for clear + 2-3 day project + lower VOC
Site-finished hardwood
vs
Prefinished hardwood
site-finished for seamless look + custom stain; prefinished for faster install + aluminum-oxide hardness
Sand and refinish (full)
vs
Screen and recoat (light)
full refinish for deep scratches + worn finish; screen-and-recoat for refresh every 3-5 years
Dustless sanding system
vs
Traditional sanding
dustless for occupied homes + allergies; traditional for vacant homes + budget
Red oak
vs
White oak
red oak for traditional warm-brown stain takers; white oak for modern gray + cooler tones + harder